Consumer Reports is one of the most dependable sources for car reviews and reliability. After all, the organization goes one step further than most media outlets and anonymously buys cars (about 60 each year) it then assesses for thousands of miles.
- Top Ten Small Suvs 2017
- Most Reliable Used Small Suv 2017
- Most Reliable Compact Suv 2017
- Most Reliable Compact Suv 2017 Models
That results in unbiased reviews and accurate reliability data. So when Consumer Reports releases a 'best and worst' list based on road tests, we tend to take it seriously.
The consumer magazine has picked the best and worst SUVs its test editors reviewed last year, based on the scores received by the respective models. Consumer Reports bases its scores on ride, handling, braking, acceleration, fuel economy, quietness, interior room, and ease of use — to name just the most important criteria.
Reliability, owner satisfaction, and safety are also included. So, without further ado, here are 2017's winners and losers in the SUV and truck segments.
These vehicles topped Consumer Reports' list of most reliable 3-year-old used cars and SUVs, based on our exclusive surveys. Product Reviews. Used Compact Cars With the Best Fuel Economy. News’ Top-Scoring Compact SUVs From 2017. The 2017 model year is over, for all intents and purposes, which makes this a great time for shoppers. Car dealerships are trying to clear out vehicles from the past year to make room for incoming 2018 vehicles. Remember, though, that not all deals are necessarily good deals. 11 Most Reliable Small SUVs in 2017; Facebook Twitter. 11 Most Reliable Small SUVs in 2017. Evarts September 26, 2017 Photo: BMW of North America, LLC. This buyer’s guide highlights the top-rated 2014 small SUVs that receive a Power Circle Rating of 5 out of a possible 5 for vehicle dependability after 3 years of ownership. Top-Ranked Cars, Trucks, and SUVs in the J.D. Vehicle Dependability Study. Learn More about the 2017 U.S. Vehicle Dependability Study. Opening our top 10 most reliable cars is the striking CH-R small SUV from Toyota.It scores an impressive 95.95% for reliability, although 14.3% of owners reported a fault of some kind, which is.
Subcompact SUVs: Subaru Crosstrek (Best) and Fiat 500X (Worst)
The Crosstrek (sold as the XV in Europe) is essentially a jacked-up previous-generation Impreza that offers a good compromise between basic off-road capabilities and on-road handling. While the ride is stiff, the cabin is rather noisy, and the 148 hp 2.0-liter four-cylinder engine has to work hard, fuel economy is a reasonable 26 mpg. An all-new model based on the latest Impreza arrives this summer.
As for the Fiat 500X, it shares the platform with the Jeep Renegade but isn't as capable off-road. That was FCA's intention because the 500X was envisioned it as a crossover alternative to the Renegade. Sadly, looks are about the only attractive thing about the 500X. It has a stiff ride, noisy cabin, poor visibility, annoying vibration at idle, and unsupportive seats. Fuel economy (23 mpg overall) is not impressive for a vehicle this size.
Compact SUVs: Subaru Forester (Best) and Jeep Cherokee (Worst)
Another winner from Subaru, the Forester convinced CR test editors with its spacious interior, numerous safety features, impressive crashworthiness, and great visibility. And, with 26 mpg overall, fuel economy is remarkable for a car fitted as standard with AWD. On top of that, the Forester offers a supple ride and secure handling, but engine noise is too high at times. Finally, controls are intuitive and easy to use, as is the recently-updated infotainment system.
In the loser's corner, there's another FCA product, the Jeep Cherokee. Too unrefined in comparison with competitors, the Cherokee comes fitted as standard with a slow 2.4-liter four-cylinder engine that returns an embarrassing 22 mpg overall. The nine-speed automatic is neither responsive nor refined, and the ride is bouncy. The best version is the 3.2-liter V6 in Limited trim, with the Trailhawk version targeting off-road enthusiasts. The Cherokee also suffers from below-average reliability.
Midsize SUVs: Toyota Highlander (Best) and Jeep Wrangler (Worst)
See a pattern here? The winner is another Japanese model, the Toyota Highlander, which tops the category thanks to a cushy ride, responsive handling, and generous cabin space — the Highlander can seat up to eight people on three rows of seats. The standard 3.5-liter V6 engine is punchy and got an eight-speed auto for 2017. It returns 20 mpg overall, with the Hybrid offering 25 mph. An array of safety features is standard for 2017.
Despite its remarkable off-road capabilities, the Wrangler lags behind the competition as an everyday vehicle. Ride quality is poor, and handling is cumbersome. Refinement is a strange notion to the Wrangler, which suffers from a noisy interior at highway speeds and uncomfortable seats. The 3.6-liter V6 with the five-speed auto returned just 17 mpg in Consumer Reports' tests. Here's hoping the next Wrangler will be much better.
Large SUVs: Dodge Durango (Best) and Toyota Sequoia (Worst)
Finally a winning FCA product, the Dodge Durango. Combining workhorse utility with many creature comforts, Dodge's big SUV offers responsive handling, a composed ride, a spacious three-row interior, and generous cargo room. The eight-speed automatic is refined and improves performance and fuel economy with both the V6 and V8 engines. Finally, the optional UConnect 8.4-inch infotainment system is one of the best in the segment.
In the opposite corner, the Toyota Sequoia suffers from extremely poor fuel economy (15 mpg), firm ride, and clumsy handling. However, the eight-passenger cabin is massive, although it's a high step-in to get inside.
Luxury Compact SUVs: Porsche Macan (Best) and Land Rover Discovery Sport (Worst)
The verdict is hardly a surprise, for the Macan has topped every comparison test we've seen so far. It's the sports car of the luxury compact SUV segment, offering a steady and controlled ride, a sumptuous cabin, and exhilarating performance — particularly with one of the three 3.0-liter V6 turbo engines that deliver between 340 and 400 hp.
The Discovery Sport is a disappointment coming from the Land Rover brand. The standard four-cylinder turbocharged engine is paired with a lazy and unrefined transmission, the ride is stiff, and handling is not worthy of the 'Sport' moniker at all. Furthermore, the cabin is rather modest for a luxury product, and the infotainment system is slow. Reliability is also predicted to be below average. At least it's capable off-road.
Luxury Midsized/Large SUVs: Audi Q7 (Best) and Cadillac Escalade (Worst)
Consumer Reports rates the Audi Q7 as one of the best vehicles they've ever tested. The luxury three-row SUV offers a powerful supercharged 3.0-liter V6 and a very smooth eight-speed auto that deliver effortless acceleration and 20 mpg overall. It's also a very quiet vehicle, with a roomy and high-quality interior. The ride may be a little too firm for some, but Audi also offers an optional air suspension. The handling is responsive and inspires confidence.
It may be the quintessential 'bling' SUV, but the Cadillac Escalade lags behind rivals in most areas. It has an overly stiff ride, poor handling, and despite the massive footprint, it doesn't offer a roomy interior. The second-row seats aren't very comfortable, and space is tight on the third row (unless you opt for the longer ESV version). The complicated CUE infotainment system and worst-in-class reliability are also big drawbacks.
Choosing a new vehicle is no small feat, and once you’ve successfully selected your ride you want to be able to rest assured that it’s a reliable vehicle that will stand the test of time and provide you with everything you need. From safety features to durability, makes and models vary widely on how reliable you can count on them to be in the long run. Reliability measures consider road test scores (ride, acceleration, fuel economy, noise levels, space, braking, etc.) and performance and problems of past vehicle generations.
Browse this list of vehicles for your next dependable ride.
Acura MDX SUV
The Acura MDX has a reputation for reliability. It’s a three-row luxury SUV with a spacious, quiet and comfortable cabin that can seat up to seven passengers. The V6 engine provides smooth, sure acceleration and the optional SH-AWD system can enhance the handling and ensure the vehicle is stable and agile in all weather conditions. The MDX comes with several features and is offered in three trim levels, with an optional Technology package that contains a navigation system, Bluetooth, USB ports and adaptive cruise control. The backup camera and optional blind-spot monitoring, lane departure warning and upgraded lights all contribute to excellent safety ratings.
Subaru Forester
The Forester is an affordable option with excellent crash test ratings and top-notch safety equipment. It gets good fuel economy at an average of 26 mpg and provides a smooth, comfortable ride in a spacious interior. The Forester also comes with an intuitive infotainment and connectivity system that uses a well-functioning touch screen. Opt for the available EyeSight system and you’ll also get forward-collision warning to further improve the safety of all your riders.
Nissan Murano
Top Ten Small Suvs 2017
The Murano has a reputation as being a refined and luxurious SUV that still manages to be safety-focused and fuel efficient. It boasts an impressive list of safety features including Around View Monitor, a 360-degree imaging camera system that improves surrounding visibility and assists drivers in avoiding collisions. Technology abounds in the comfort features as well with “zero gravity” seats that provide a smooth and luxe feeling ride. The Murano was among the top 6 rated midsize SUVs in J.D. Power’s 2016 annual U.S. Vehicle Dependability Study with both an overall quality rating and an overall performance and design rating of 5 out of 5.
Porsche Macan
The Porsche Macan is real luxury. It’s a powerful, compact SUV with excellent handling and signature Porsche features including the seats, controls, finishes and high-end details. All-wheel drive comes standard and the Macan comes in a choice of three engines and five trims. With leather upholstery, precise steering and powerful acceleration, you can get your quality ride in a suave and sporty package.
The athletic performance of the Macan is coupled with solid reliability, making it a quality vehicle as well as a sophisticated one.
Lexus RX 350
Most Reliable Used Small Suv 2017
The Lexus RX 350 ranks in the top-tier of luxury midsize SUVs and provides incredible value in its class. The 3.5 liter V6 engine is paired with an eight-speed automatic and the vehicle gets above average fuel economy on front wheel drive. The two-row SUV is known for solid reliability and a quality package of standard features including the Lexus Safety System which contributes to preventing potential collisions.
Most Reliable Compact Suv 2017
Audi Q7
The Audi Q7 is a luxury midsized/large SUV with a quality reputation amongst drivers. It received 10 out of 10 on Kelley Blue Book Consumer Rating and was tops among their consumer rated SUVs of 2017. The Q7 is a three-row model with a supercharged 3.0 liter V6 engine. It has an optional advanced safety system that includes automatic emergency braking and lane-keep assist. The ride in the Q7 is a comfortable, tranquil, luxurious experience. With effortless acceleration, a responsive and reliable handle and beautiful finishes on the interior, it’s both a sophisticated and reliable vehicle.
Most Reliable Compact Suv 2017 Models
Chevrolet Equinox
The Equinox gives great value at a relatively low price, quality interior and above average safety and reliability scores. It is a spacious ride for a compact SUV and comfortably seats 5, with a six-speed automatic transmission. The Equinox has consistently scored high on reliability and been top of its class in the past few years. In J.D. Power’s 2016 annual U.S. Vehicle Dependability Study it scored 4.5 out of 5 for reliability and 4 out of 5 for both overall quality and overall performance and design and was among the top 6 of all vehicles.